Early access: the reports are free for now.Use code BRICKROADTEST at checkout.See prices

Behavioural / structured or Collaborative problem solving?

Behavioural / structured: A clear rule, a known consequence, no negotiation in the moment. Collaborative problem solving: Kids do well if they can, so find the missing skill, together, in advance.

The difference between Behavioural / structured and Collaborative problem solving is mostly one axis: consequences. Behavioural / structured leans firmly toward “the same consequence, every time”; Collaborative problem solving leans toward “no imposed consequences at all”. They agree, more than most people expect, on where guidance comes from, risk and physical closeness. Neither is the correct one. What follows is what each asks of a parent, and where the difference actually shows up on a Tuesday.

Behaviour is dealt with as behaviour. The rule is stated in advance, the consequence follows at once and the same way every time, and the discussion happens later or not at all, because the discussion is what most children are after. Reward systems run the same way in reverse. It is the most reliably effective approach in the short run, and it makes the fewest claims about anything else.

What it asks of you

  • Near-perfect consistency. The method is the consistency, and fails without it
  • Not explaining yourself mid-incident, which feels wrong to most parents who try it
  • Every adult in the house running the same system
  • Accepting that it manages behaviour and does not claim to do more

Greene's starting point is that difficult behaviour is a skill problem, not a motivation problem, so rewards and punishments aim at the wrong thing. You list the specific situations that reliably go wrong, then solve each one with the child, in a calm moment and never in the middle of it, until you find a solution you can both live with. It is the most step-by-step approach here, and the most demanding on the adult in advance.

What it asks of you

  • Doing the work when nothing is going wrong, which is when nobody feels like it
  • Hearing your child's concern all the way out before offering yours
  • Letting go of solutions you already had in mind
  • Keeping a list, literally. The method does not run from memory
Side by side

Where they differ

Behavioural / structured is the filled marker, Collaborative problem solving the hollow one. Widest difference first.

D3Consequences
no imposed consequences at allthe same consequence, every time

Behavioural / structured leans firmly toward “the same consequence, every time”; Collaborative problem solving leans toward “no imposed consequences at all”.

D2Who decides
we work it out with themthe adults decide, and explain

Behavioural / structured leans toward “the adults decide, and explain”; Collaborative problem solving leans firmly toward “we work it out with them”.

R2Behaviour or feeling
what they didwhat is underneath it

Behavioural / structured leans toward “what they did”; Collaborative problem solving leans toward “what is underneath it”.

D4Praise and rewards
describing what is therepraising and rewarding freely

Behavioural / structured leans toward “praising and rewarding freely”; Collaborative problem solving leans toward “describing what is there”.

D1Structure
we take the day as it comesa predictable rhythm and clear rules

Behavioural / structured leans firmly toward “a predictable rhythm and clear rules”; Collaborative problem solving leans a little toward “a predictable rhythm and clear rules”.

A3Expectation
their own pace, no pushhigh expectations, and pushing

Behavioural / structured leans in the middle; Collaborative problem solving leans toward “their own pace, no push”.

R1Response to distress
let them work through itstep in and settle them straight away

Behavioural / structured leans a little toward “let them work through it”; Collaborative problem solving leans a little toward “step in and settle them straight away”.

C2Bandwidthwhat your life allows
running on emptyhaving room for this

Behavioural / structured leans in the middle; Collaborative problem solving leans toward “having room for this”.

Where they agree

Usually more than the argument between them suggests.

  • Where guidance comes from. Both lean toward “research, books, a named method”.
  • Risk. Both lean in the middle.
  • Physical closeness. Both lean a little toward “their own space, early”.
  • How full the week is. Both lean a little toward “unstructured time, boredom is fine”.
Asked a lot

Behavioural / structured or Collaborative problem solving: the questions people ask

Is Behavioural / structured better than Collaborative problem solving?
Neither is the correct one. Behavioural / structured and Collaborative problem solving each work for the families they suit. Which fits depends on what you value and on what your week allows, and nothing here will tell you which one of those you should want.
What is the main difference between Behavioural / structured and Collaborative problem solving?
Mostly one thing: consequences. Behavioural / structured leans firmly toward “the same consequence, every time”; Collaborative problem solving leans toward “no imposed consequences at all”.
Which asks more of a parent, Behavioural / structured or Collaborative problem solving?
Collaborative problem solving asks more on bandwidth. That is about fit, not about doing it wrong: an approach that asks for more than your week has is the one that stops working after a fortnight.

Neither of these is the correct one

Which fits depends on what you value and on what your week allows. The second is the half nobody writes about. The questions score both.

See which one you already use